Remember when a private island day meant a beach, a burger and a long tender ride back to the ship? Those days are pretty much over. Royal Caribbean, Carnival and Norwegian have all poured a boat load of money into their Bahamas islands, and every one of them has figured out the same trick. Give you a nice free day, then put the really good stuff behind a paywall.
If you’re sailing out of Florida this winter, there’s a good chance Perfect Day CocoCay, Celebration Key, RelaxAway, Half Moon Cay or Great Stirrup Cay is on your itinerary. And now that Carnival and Princess have changed the rules on drink packages ashore, the math on which island gives you the best day has changed too. So here’s what’s free at each one, what’s going to cost you, and where your package actually works.
First things first. Prices bounce around by ship, by sailing and by how close you are to your cruise. The numbers below are what’s been the average recently, so use them as a guide but always check with your cruise line before locking in a budget.
The Quick Version
Perfect Day CocoCay
CocoCay is the island that started it all, and is pretty much the benchmark for others to copy. You walk right off the ship at the pier, and the free stuff alone can fill your whole day. Oasis Lagoon is the largest freshwater pool in the Caribbean. Throw in Chill Island, South Beach, Splashaway Bay for the kids and free food at Skipper’s Grill and Chill Grill, and you never have to spend a dime.
Of course, Royal Caribbean would really like you to drop some cash and there are definitely opportunities to do just that. Thrill Waterpark has been listed anywhere from the mid $40s to over $100 depending on the day. Hideaway Beach, the adults only area with its own pool and DJ, usually runs around $50. Coco Beach Club day passes start under $100, and those overwater cabanas with the slides straight into the ocean start around $1,000. Then there’s the Up, Up and Away balloon, the zipline, snorkeling and jet skis.
The thing I like most about CocoCay is that your drink package works there. You paid for it, you get to use it at the beach. That’s how it should work, and it’s exactly what Carnival and Princess are now catching up on. Royal Caribbean also opened the Secret Garden Bar on the island over the summer, and in case you missed it, the island quietly dropped the “at” from its name. It’s officially Perfect Day CocoCay now. Why? Your guess is as good as mine.
If you’re happy with the free side and you’ve got a package, CocoCay is tough to beat. Just decide what you’re willing to pay for before you get off the ship, because once you’re standing there in the sun, Royal Caribbean is very good at selling you upgrades.

Celebration Key
Celebration Key on Grand Bahama is Carnival’s answer to CocoCay. Carnival splits it into what it calls portals. Paradise Plaza is the hub with the Suncastle in the middle. Calypso Lagoon is the adults side with a swim up bar and a DJ. Starfish Lagoon is the family side with a splash pad. Lokono Cove has Bahamian artisan shops, and Pearl Cove Beach Club is the paid adults only area.
Your fare covers the beaches, both lagoons, most of the loungers, the Suncastle body slides and the live music. Food is where it gets a little tricky. You get one casual meal included, and that’s it. If you’re used to an all-you-can-eat BBQ buffet, you won’t find that here. Bottled water and soda cost extra too.
Pearl Cove runs around $100 with a welcome drink, about $140 with an open bar and about $180 if you add lunch. The racing slides on the Suncastle are about $15. Lagoon cabanas have been listed around $600 to $900, and the Supervillas can go past $2,500.
Right now, your CHEERS! package does nothing for you at Celebration Key. You pay for every drink. That changes for port visits on or after February 1, 2027, when Carnival’s drink packages finally start working at both Celebration Key and Half Moon Cay. Princess Plus and Premier start working at Celebration Key that same day. Anything you order ashore counts toward your daily drink limit. Not everybody’s thrilled about it, which I wrote about in Who Wouldn’t Want Drink Packages at Private Islands? Apparently Some Cruisers, mostly because people are worried what it’ll do to the price once Carnival’s dynamic pricing kicks in on December 1.
Carnival isn’t done with Celebration Key, either. In 2028 it’s adding a heated beach entry pool with a swim up bar, a group waterslide and a kids aqua zone. In 2030 comes an 18 slide waterpark, a lazy river Carnival says will be the longest in the industry, and an adults only area with an infinity pool. No word yet on which of those will cost extra, but I think we all know how that usually goes.

RelaxAway, Half Moon Cay
I still can’t get over that name. But the island itself has never been in better shape. Carnival opened the expanded north side on June 1, along with a new pier that lets its Excel class ships call for the first time. Not every ship uses the pier, though, Holland America cruisers will still uses tenders to reach their side of the island.
Half Moon Cay is still a beach island first. Your fare gets you that long crescent of sand that it’s named after, loungers and umbrellas, the tram, the Papaya Pathway and a barbecue lunch at the beach grills. Cabanas, daybeds, excursions and drinks are extra.
Holland America, which bought the island back in 1996, added a few things of its own this fall. Its new Beach Club opened in October for $150 a person and that gets you a private stretch of beach with daybeds, waiter service, an open bar, lunch and snorkel gear. It also added a new food pavilion, renovated bars, more daybeds and four pickleball courts, and all of that is open to everybody. Pickleball. On a Bahamas beach. Of course. Carnival’s also opening Serenity Beach in spring 2027, a free adults only area for guests 21 and up.
Drink packages are a little messy here because it depends on which ship you came in on. Princess Plus and Premier drink benefits start working on the island November 23. Carnival’s follow on February 1. Holland America drink packages do not work ashore.
If your idea of a perfect island day is a chair, a drink and a really pretty beach, this is your island. Just don’t go looking for waterslides.

Great Stirrup Cay
For years, Great Stirrup Cay was the island people complained about with long tender lines and not a heck of a lot to do. Norwegian got the message and gave the island a complete overhaul. A new pier opened at the end of December 2025, so you walk off the ship, and there’s a lot more waiting for you when you do.
The big one is Great Tides Waterpark, which opened September 4. It has 19 slides across four zones, including the 170 foot Tidal Tower with eight slides on its own, plus the Wandering River, an 800 foot moving river that’s not quite “lazy.” Day passes have been running around $90 to $100, kids three and under are free, and waterpark cabanas run about $1,000 to $1,200 for up to six people. Passes are limited, so book early if you want one. I put it up against CocoCay’s waterpark in Waterpark Showdown: Great Stirrup Cay vs. CocoCay.
The free side is a lot better than it used to be too. You get the beaches, the tram, Great Life Lagoon (a heated pool with swim up bars), Splash Harbor for the kids, Hammock Bay and free food. If you absolutely feel the need to spend money, there’s the adults only Vibe Shore Club at around $110 and the Silver Cove Ocean Villas at around $600 for up to six.
And your Free at Sea package works on the island, waterpark included. Norwegian got that one right.
Great Stirrup Cay went from the island everybody griped about to a legit rival for CocoCay, especially if you’ve got kids who want slides.

So Which One Should You Pick?
Whatever island’s on your itinerary, open the cruise planner before you sail and figure out what you’re paying for ahead of time. It’s a lot easier to say no to a $1,000 cabana from your couch than it is from the beach. And if you’re on the fence about a drink package, run your numbers through our Carnival drink package calculator before you buy.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do you have to tender at any of these private islands?
CocoCay, Celebration Key and Great Stirrup Cay all have piers, so you walk off the ship. Half Moon Cay has a new pier too, but Holland America ships still anchor and tender guests in, so check how your ship gets you ashore.
Which private islands let you use your drink package?
Royal Caribbean packages work at CocoCay, and Norwegian’s Free at Sea works at Great Stirrup Cay. Princess Plus and Premier drink benefits work at Half Moon Cay starting November 23, 2026, and at Celebration Key starting February 1, 2027. Carnival’s packages start working at both of its islands on February 1, 2027. Holland America drink packages do not work at Half Moon Cay.
Is food free on cruise private islands?
Mostly, but not all the same. CocoCay, Great Stirrup Cay and Half Moon Cay all have free food. Celebration Key includes one casual meal per guest, and you pay for anything after that.
Which island has the best adults only area?
It depends on what you want. Hideaway Beach at CocoCay is usually the cheapest paid option. Pearl Cove at Celebration Key and the Holland America Beach Club at Half Moon Cay both include an open bar. Half Moon Cay also gets a free adults only Serenity Beach in spring 2027.
Is the Great Tides Waterpark worth it?
If you’ve got kids or teens who love slides, it’s probably the best money you’ll spend on the island. If you just want to relax, the free Great Life Lagoon is a better bet.

