Sailing nowNieuw Amsterdam Southern Caribbean· Day 1
Menu
Cruise News

Costa Concordia Captain Francesco Schettino Released on Probation After Nine Years

Francesco Schettino is a free man. Well, sort of. The former captain of the Costa Concordia walked out of Rome’s Rebibbia prison on Friday evening after more than nine years behind bars, according to Euronews. The Rome Supervisory Court granted him release on probation after reviewing how he behaved in prison and how he did in its rehabilitation programme.

His lawyer, Francesca Carnicelli, said prison staff gave his participation in that programme an extremely positive assessment, and that all the conditions were in place for the alternative measure to be granted. Plenty of survivors and victims’ families won’t see it that way, and honestly, I don’t blame them.

For a lot of us who cruise regularly, the name Schettino still stings. So with the news out, I wanted to look back at what actually happened that night off Giglio, how it played out in court, the unbelievable salvage job that followed, and the very real ways it changed what you and I do every time we step on a ship.

Where I Was When It Happened

On the night of January 13, 2012, I was on board Regent’s Seven Seas Navigator. I remember being glued to the TV as the drama played out, watching in total amazement that something like this could happen to a modern ship packed with all the latest technology.

- Advertisement -

The funny thing is, back when I wrote about it later that year, what stuck with me was how little anyone on board actually talked about it. Passengers and crew alike were watching the coverage, but nobody really wanted to discuss it out loud. I think we just didn’t want to think too hard about it while we were floating around in the Atlantic ourselves. When you’re on a ship watching another ship lie on its side in the water, it hits a little differently than watching it from your couch.

What Happened Off Giglio

The Costa Concordia left Civitavecchia, the port for Rome, that Friday evening with 4,229 people on board, 3,206 passengers and 1,023 crew. She was only about six years old, a 114,500 ton Fincantieri build that cost roughly 450 million euros, and she was one of the flagships of Costa Cruises, part of Carnival Corporation.

Instead of following the planned route, Schettino steered the ship close to the island of Giglio to do what’s called a “salute,” a showy sail-by close to shore with the horn blaring. It was a maneuver he’d done before. This time the ship struck rocks, and the impact tore a gash about 35 meters long in the port side of the hull. Water poured in, the ship lost power, and she eventually listed heavily and ran aground near Punta Gabbianara, partially sinking just off the island’s harbor.

What made it so much worse was what came next. The bridge told the coast guard they were simply dealing with a blackout. The general alarm wasn’t sounded until about an hour after the collision, and by the time the evacuation really got going, the ship was leaning so far that the lifeboats on one side were basically useless. People jumped into the cold January water in the dark. Giglio’s tiny population, around 800 people, turned out to help bring people ashore.

And one more detail that’s easy to forget: about 700 of the passengers had only boarded at Civitavecchia that evening. Under the rules at the time, the muster drill didn’t have to happen until within 24 hours of boarding, so those folks had never been shown where to go or what to do. That one detail ended up changing the entire industry, which I’ll get to in a minute.

- Advertisement -
Partially capsized Costa Concordia (Photo credit: Wikipedia user @Rvongher)

The Captain Who Left Before His Passengers

There’s a long-standing rule of the sea that the captain is the last one off. Italian law actually backs that up, since a master is required to stay aboard and direct the evacuation until everyone is off. Schettino didn’t. Investigators found he left the ship in a lifeboat at around 12:34 a.m., while as late as 3:44 a.m. there were still dozens of people on board waiting to be rescued. The evacuation wasn’t declared complete until after 6 a.m.

That’s what led to the most famous phone call in cruise history. Coast Guard Captain Gregorio De Falco, the duty officer in Livorno, ordered Schettino again and again to get back on his ship using the rope ladder at the bow and tell rescuers how many people were still trapped. Schettino gave excuses, at one point saying it was dark, and De Falco’s furious “Vada a bordo!” (get back on board, with a little extra Italian flavor I’ll leave out) became a national catchphrase. The Italian press started calling Schettino “Captain Coward.” His explanation later? He said the ship was tilting so badly that he tripped and fell into the lifeboat. Nobody bought it then, and nobody buys it now.

In the end, 32 people lost their lives, passengers and crew both. One of them was Russel Rebello, an Indian waiter from Mumbai who survivors say spent his final moments helping passengers reach the lifeboats, reportedly even giving his own life jacket away. His body was the last one to be found, which didn’t happen until November 2014, when workers dismantling the ship in Genoa discovered his remains in a cabin.

The Trial, the Conviction and the Appeals

Schettino was placed under house arrest days after the disaster in his hometown of Meta di Sorrento, near Naples. His trial opened in Grosseto in July 2013, and he ended up standing there alone. Costa Cruises sidestepped criminal charges by accepting limited responsibility and paying a fine of about one million euros, and five other employees, including the helmsman and the head of Costa’s crisis unit, took plea bargains with sentences between 18 months and just under three years. None of them went to prison.

In February 2015, the court convicted Schettino of multiple counts of manslaughter, causing a shipwreck and abandoning his passengers. Prosecutors, who called him a “reckless idiot,” wanted more than 26 years. The judges gave him 16 years and one month. He insisted throughout that others shared the blame and that his maneuvering after the collision actually saved lives.

In Italy you don’t go to prison until your appeals run out, so it took a while. The Florence Court of Appeals upheld the sentence in May 2016 and added a five-year ban from working in the maritime industry. Italy’s highest court, the Court of Cassation, confirmed it for good on May 12, 2017, and that’s when Schettino finally started serving time at Rebibbia.

He’s been trying to get out early for a while now. Around the halfway point of his sentence he applied for “semi-liberty,” which would have let him leave prison during the day to work, and there were reports he might end up digitizing documents for the Vatican. He eventually withdrew that request when the work arrangement fell through. This time, the court said yes to probation instead.

Now, about the sentence. A lot of people, me included, look at 16 years for 32 lives and feel like it’s not much. One survivor at the original verdict pointed out it worked out to about six months per person who died. On the other hand, the fact that he was the only one who sat in a cell, while the company paid a fine and walked, has always bothered folks on both sides of the debate. Both things can be true.

- Advertisement -

The Biggest Salvage Job Ever Attempted

If you never followed the salvage, it’s honestly one of the most incredible engineering stories of our lifetime. The ship was declared a total loss, but you can’t just leave a 114,500 ton wreck sitting in a marine sanctuary off a tourist island.

First crews had to pump out the fuel so it wouldn’t leak into the sea, which wrapped up in March 2012. That April, a partnership between American company Titan Salvage and Italy’s Micoperi won the contract to remove her in one piece. The plan was something called parbuckling, which means rotating the ship upright instead of cutting it up where it lay.

They built an underwater steel platform, welded huge buoyancy tanks called sponsons to the exposed side and, in September 2013, about 20 months after the accident, slowly rolled the ship upright. It took about 19 hours, and a lot of us watched it live online. Then they attached more sponsons to the other side, and on July 14, 2014 the Concordia floated again. She was towed roughly 200 miles to Genoa, arriving at the end of July 2014, and the scrapping was finally finished in July 2017.

Hundreds of specialists from around the world worked on it, including about 100 divers. Sadly, the ship claimed one more life during the effort, when a Spanish salvage diver died in February 2014 after cutting his leg on a metal sheet underwater. The whole operation, including compensation, refloating, towing and scrapping, cost somewhere around 1.5 billion euros, roughly $2 billion, or more than three times what the ship cost to build.

Costa Concordia being scrapped in the Superbacino dock in Genoa, Italy. (Photo credit: Wikipedia user @G.jenewein)

What Changed for Cruisers Because of the Concordia

Here’s the part that affects every one of us. Within weeks, before regulators could even get moving, the Cruise Lines International Association made muster drills mandatory before a ship leaves port for all its member lines. Remember those passengers who’d boarded that evening and never had a drill? That’s never supposed to happen again. The International Maritime Organization followed by writing it into the international Safety of Life at Sea rules (SOLAS), and the change took effect in January 2015.

- Advertisement -

That was just the start. Cruise lines also adopted:

  • Tighter restrictions on who can visit the bridge, especially during critical moments like sailing near shore
  • Extra life jackets stored near muster stations, not just in cabins
  • Stricter voyage planning, so deviations from the approved route have to be planned and shared with the crew
  • Required crew practice launching and loading lifeboats at least every six months
  • Rules to secure heavy objects so they don’t become hazards in a severe list

Costa itself started monitoring the real-time position of every ship in its fleet against the route the captain filed before departure. Further down the road, new SOLAS rules that kicked in in 2020 drew on lessons from the Concordia to make newly built passenger ships more stable and better at staying afloat after flooding, and required evacuation analysis early in a ship’s design.

Today a lot of lines have moved to e-muster, where you watch the safety video on your phone or TV and then check in at your station. It’s way more convenient than standing shoulder to shoulder on deck in your life jacket, but please don’t treat it like a box to tick. I wrote more about that in why your muster drill matters. The Concordia is exactly why it exists.

Cruising is still one of the safest ways to travel, and I’ve never once let the Concordia keep me off a ship. But nearly 15 years later, it’s still the disaster that reshaped how this industry handles safety, and it all traces back to one captain’s decision to show off and then another decision to leave before his passengers did.

Schettino has served his time according to the court, and that’s how the system works. But for the families of those 32 people, and for anyone who was on board that night, I don’t think release on probation changes much of anything. Next time you’re standing at your muster station checking in, take a second to think about why you’re there.

Scott Sanfilippo
Scott is the captain (well, founder and editor) behind Scott's Cruises! After making waves as an eCommerce pioneer during the dot-com boom of the '90s and '00s, Scott decided the only surfing he wanted to do was on the actual ocean. He’s been blogging about his nautical adventures since 2005, transforming into a full-time professional vacationer. Over the last two decades, he's racked up nearly a quarter-million nautical miles, conquered almost every ocean cruise line, explored 50+ different ships, and spent hundreds of nights on mattresses that, quite frankly, could have used a pillow-top.
- Advertisement -

Leave a Comment