Sailing nowNieuw Amsterdam Panama Canal· Day 11
Menu
Carnival Cruise Line News

Why Carnival’s Next New Ships Are Getting Smaller

When Carnival announced a brand new ship class yesterday, the part that jumped out at me wasn’t the LNG or the shipyard. It was the size. After years of building bigger and bigger, Carnival’s next new design comes in at about 130,000 gross tons with around 1,650 cabins, which works out to roughly 3,300 guests at double occupancy. Compare that with Excel Class ships like Mardi Gras and Carnival Celebration, which can carry well over 6,000 people when every bunk’s filled, or Carnival Destiny and the Ace Class at around 8,000, and that’s a real change in direction.

If you missed everything else that came out of Carnival’s “Next Wave” event, including drink packages finally being honored at Celebration Key and Half Moon Cay, here’s my full recap.

Here’s what we know about the new ships so far. Fincantieri’s building two of them at its Marghera shipyard in Italy, with deliveries in 2033 and 2035, and they’ll run primarily on LNG. Carnival Corporation’s also calling the design a multi-brand platform, which means the same basic ship could show up at some of its other lines down the road, like the Vista-class. What Carnival hasn’t really said is why it’s going smaller. But when you look at what Carnival’s fleet looks like right now, the answer is pretty clear.

Carnival Horizon
Carnival Horizon

Carnival’s Fleet Is Older Than You Might Think

Carnival sails 29 ships today, and you can see how every one of them stacks up in my Carnival Cruise Line fleet guide. The big new ships get all the attention, but here’s the thing a lot of people don’t realize: 15 of those 29 ships were delivered in 2005 or earlier. Looking at capacity figures, those 15 ships hold about 38,900 of Carnival’s roughly 94,400 lower berths. So on any given night, about four out of every ten Carnival guests are sleeping on a ship that’s more than 20 years old.

- Advertisement -

Now look at how old the oldest of them will be when the first ship in the new class shows up in 2033:

Carnival Sunshine
Delivered 1996 (as Carnival Destiny)
About 3,000 guests
37 years old in 2033
Carnival Elation
Delivered 1998 (Fantasy Class)
About 2,190 guests
35 years old in 2033
Carnival Paradise
Delivered 1998 (Fantasy Class)
About 2,120 guests
35 years old in 2033
Carnival Sunrise
Delivered 1999 (as Carnival Triumph)
About 2,980 guests
34 years old in 2033
Carnival Radiance
Delivered 2000 (as Carnival Victory)
About 2,980 guests
33 years old in 2033
Carnival Spirit
Delivered 2001 (Spirit Class)
About 2,130 guests
32 years old in 2033
Carnival Pride
Delivered 2001 (Spirit Class)
About 2,130 guests
32 years old in 2033
Carnival Adventure
Delivered 2001
About 2,640 guests
32 years old in 2033

And right behind them are Carnival Legend, Carnival Conquest and Carnival Encounter from 2002, plus Carnival Glory, Valor, Miracle and Liberty from 2003 through 2005.

We’ve already seen what Carnival does with ships at that age. Carnival Ecstasy and Carnival Sensation both left the fleet in the last couple of years after more than three decades of service, and Elation and Paradise are now the last two Fantasy Class ships still sailing. Carnival Sunshine’s an example of how a big makeover can stretch a ship’s life, but there’s only so long you can keep refreshing a hull that was built in the mid-90s. Older ships burn more fuel, cost more to maintain and get tougher to bring up to newer environmental rules.

Carnival Paradise
Carnival Paradise

Why 3,300 Guests Is the Sweet Spot

Here’s where the size starts to make a lot of sense. The three Destiny Class ships (Sunshine, Sunrise and Radiance) carry about 3,000 guests each. The Conquest Class ships are right around 2,980. Even Carnival’s 2,100-guest Spirit Class ships are a lot closer to 3,300 than they are to 8,000. This new class is basically sized to step into the role those ships play today, not to become another floating theme park.

- Advertisement -

If Carnival tried to replace those ships with more Excel or Ace Class giants, it wouldn’t just be a bigger ship. It’d be a completely different vacation, with a limitation on which ports they can visit. Mega ships need long piers, deep harbors, plenty of room to turn and a cruise terminal that can move thousands of people on and off in a few hours. That’s a big reason Carnival’s largest ships mostly sail out of the biggest homeports, like PortMiami, Port Canaveral and Galveston, on short Bahamas and Caribbean runs that lean heavily on Celebration Key. A 3,300-guest ship can fit into a lot more places, both as a homeport and as a port of call, which gives Carnival room to build more interesting itineraries instead of sending everybody to the same handful of stops.

There’s also the guest experience. I talk with a lot of longtime Carnival cruisers, and plenty of them have no interest in a 6,000-plus guest ship. They like being able to walk from one end of the ship to the other without a map, finding a lounger on a sea day without becoming one of the a 7 a.m. chair hogs, and not needing body armor for the Lido at lunch. Those folks have been watching their favorite ships get older with nothing new coming in that size range. This class gives them a reason to stay loyal instead of drifting over to another line.

And here’s a number I find really interesting. Divide the gross tonnage by the guest count and you get a rough idea of how much room each guest has. At about 130,000 gross tons and 3,300 guests, the new class works out to around 39 gross tons per guest. Mardi Gras (around 180,000 gross tons) and Carnival Horizon (about 133,500 gross tons) both come in closer to 34. That’s my own rough math on the announced figures, but if it holds up, these ships won’t just be smaller. They’ll feel roomier than anything Carnival sails today. For context, that’s roughly the size of the Vista Class, which I liked a lot on my Carnival Horizon cruise this past summer, just with a few hundred fewer people on board.

Rendering of Carnival Destiny, the first Ace Class ship, at sea

Two Ships Won’t Be Enough

Two new ships in 2033 and 2035 aren’t going to replace 15 ships that’ll all be pushing 30 or older by then. Carnival Corporation now has 12 new ships on order through 2039 across Carnival Cruise Line, Princess and AIDA. Reading between the lines, I wouldn’t be surprised to see more of these mid-sized ships ordered over the next few years, either for Carnival or for sister lines, as the oldest ships in the fleet start heading for the breakers. That’s just my guess, though. Carnival hasn’t announced any retirements tied to this order.

Fun twist: the name Carnival’s reviving for the first Ace Class ship belongs to the original Carnival Destiny, the ship that broke the 100,000 gross ton barrier back in 1996 and still sails today as Carnival Sunshine. That ship was the giant of its day. Thirty years later, ships around that size are exactly what Carnival needs more of.

Scott Sanfilippo
Scott is the captain (well, founder and editor) behind Scott's Cruises! After making waves as an eCommerce pioneer during the dot-com boom of the '90s and '00s, Scott decided the only surfing he wanted to do was on the actual ocean. He’s been blogging about his nautical adventures since 2005, transforming into a full-time professional vacationer. Over the last two decades, he's racked up nearly a quarter-million nautical miles, conquered almost every ocean cruise line, explored 50+ different ships, and spent hundreds of nights on mattresses that, quite frankly, could have used a pillow-top.
- Advertisement -

Leave a Comment